What garage?? All I see when I park in garages in NYC are exotic cars. In fact we were just in there recently with my son and enjoyed the wait while they retrieved our car, they had a whole section with Lambo's, Ferraris, just about every kind of exotic car and my son liked seeing them all...
We were downtown but park more midtown, never had an issue...
If they wouldn't park an "exotic" car I wouldn't park any of my cars there as they seem to "anticipate" the possibility of something happening..they don't care to be careful it seems..but its their choice I guess, just odd they would pass up the $$$